Who's the expert?

As I was wandering around the web a short while ago I followed a link to a website design site.

Now, I’m sure that you can tell that while this blog is ‘OK’ to look at, I’m no design expert. There are many things I wish I could do which would go well beyond just hacking a template until I get something close to what I want. Never the less I’m relatively happy with what I’ve done.

The interesting thing was that the website design site was truly awful. Here was someone offering their services at a considerable hourly rate and even to the untrained eye their own site is cramped, the colours don’t really work and it certainly didn’t inspire me to want to use their services. They are offering to review other sites and give feedback on improvements for just $150. Imagine that – $150 just to look at your site and then they’ll tell you how much they’ll charge you to fix the problems they see. I can give them a review of their own site for nothing. I don’t think they’re trying to rip anyone off, they simply have a very high opinion of their very average skills.

I wonder how many times we believe that someone is an expert just because they tell us that they are. How many times do we think they must know what they’re doing because they’re charging professional rates? I’m not just talking website design here. There are so many areas of life where people present themselves as someone who knows what they’re talking about when in reality they haven’t got a clue. How do we decide what’s good and what’s bad if it’s not our area of expertise?

How do you decide on which service or professional to use when you need to someone to provide skills you don’t have? How do you know what’s good and what’s not? How do you choose a mechanic when you really have no idea what goes on under the bonnet of your car? How do you decide on a family doctor when the most medical training you’ve ever had is how to apply a band-aid?



Do you think some of your friends would enjoy reading Who's the expert?? Please use the buttons below to share the post. Thanks.

About the author

Rodney Olsen

Rodney is a husband, father, cyclist, blogger and podcaster from Perth Western Australia.

He has worked in radio at Perth's media ministry Sonshine for over 25 years and has previously worked at ministries such as Compassion Australia and Bible Society.

The views he expresses here are his own.

View all posts

7 Comments

  • I think you have some very good points.

    I don’t really understand the whole web design thing. I think it’s the content that matters, and as long as it’s not too busy….it works for me.

    I think your web design is perfectly fine.

  • I’ve attended professional conferences, at which the registration fee was hundreds of dollars, only to hear a keynote speaker that obviously doesn’t know what they are talking about! This is a rather widespread problem Rodney. I work in the internet industry, where I find many a colleagues proclaiming themselves “social networking guru” or “online marketing genius”. My experience: most are less than mediocre in their field. The real experts don’t need a title. They are too busy getting things done to bother with self-hype.

  • Same as Chris I’ve been at a conference where I had to pay a high enough fee and one of the speakers showed a home made (from digital camera) video clip on what she thinks is good, it was aweful to sit through it.

    Yes, we’ll never know, I suppose the best is to go through word of mouth, if some one you respect recommend them then it should be good.

  • I ask for references….Satisfied customers…..I had a guy give me a bid to put in a new shower and he had never done one before…..i don’t know if he could or not…but he had guts….

Join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.